Skip to content
BIMpedia
Chapter 4 · Lesson 1 of 3Topic: Designing with the model

Analysis from the model

Energy, daylight, structure and airflow can start from the design model, but not from the same model as is. Learn what each analysis needs, and how to keep the analysis model and the design model in step.

With Nadia, architect and design lead2 min read3 quiz questions
Skip to the quiz
  • Watch out
  • What it costs
  • Experienced readers
  • Remember
  • In BIMpedia
Nadiaarchitect and design lead
Even if you do this every day, watch for this: A result is only as current as the model it was run on. Write the model version on every analysis report, and agree which design changes trigger a rerun.

Design models can feed analysis: energy use, daylight, thermal comfort, structural behaviour, airflow, acoustics. Done well, analysis moves from an occasional report to a regular check on the design. Done badly, it runs on an export that nobody can repeat, against a design that has since changed.

Basics

Each analysis tool needs a different simplification of the design. Energy tools need closed spaces and the surfaces around them. Structural tools need members as lines with nodes, supports and loads. Daylight tools need surfaces with their materials. None needs the furniture or the door handles.

Story · The study that described another building
How it goes wrong

The stage 2 energy study shows the building meeting its target, and the report goes in the design file. In stage 3 the plant room grows, the glazing changes and two floors are reorganised. Nobody reruns the study. At the stage 4 compliance check, the building fails the target by a wide margin, and the façade has already been tendered.

How it goes right

The BEP lists the analyses, the model version each used, and what triggers a rerun (changes to glazing, fabric, spaces or plant). When the glazing changes in stage 3, the study is rerun on the new version. The shortfall shows up early, while the façade can still change.

What each analysis needs

AnalysisNeeds from the modelCommon problem
EnergyClosed, bounded spaces; typed surfaces; locationMissing or open rooms; walls not bounding rooms
DaylightSurfaces with materials; windows; surroundingsGlazing with no properties; no neighbouring buildings
StructuralMembers, supports, loads, as an idealised modelPhysical and analysis models drift apart
Airflow and comfortSpaces, openings, heat sourcesSimplification not agreed with the analyst
Nadiaarchitect and design lead
Your turn. Give it about 10 min and work it out on your own before you open the model answer: that is where it sticks.
Exercise: Prepare an energy export 10 min

The analyst needs the clinic for an energy study. Put your preparation steps in order.

Check yourself

Prepare the energy export

Put the preparation steps in order.

  1. 1Check every space is modelled and bounded
  2. 2Agree with the analyst what they need
  3. 3Send it with a note of what is included
  4. 4Export and record the model version
  5. 5Set the location and orientation
  6. 6Check surfaces and windows are typed

Key takeaways

  • Each analysis needs its own simplified view of the design: spaces and surfaces for energy, members and loads for structure.
  • Model spaces and room bounding correctly; most energy exports fail because rooms are missing or open.
  • Record which design model version each analysis used, and rerun it after relevant changes.
  • Analysis results come back as decisions in the design, not as a separate model nobody updates.

Your notes

Related tool

Open an IFC file in the browser: structure, elements, properties and required-property checks.

Open IFC Inspector →

Check yourself

3 questions · 2 right to complete
  1. 1. The energy analyst says the export from your model has 'unbounded spaces' and no results. What is the most likely cause?
  2. 2. The structural engineer's analysis model differs from the structural design model: centrelines instead of solid members. Is that a problem?
  3. 3. The daylight study was run in stage 2. In stage 3, the façade's windows are reduced by 20%. What do you do?
0 of 3 answered
Next lessonEmbodied carbon from the model
Was this page useful?